The youth sports landscape is crumbling

We have forgotten the point of youth sports, and if we don’t alter our behvior someday there may be no youth sports at all.

Recently, I found out that a long-time sports reporter friend is, for now, hanging up his microphone.

“Lately the landscape has had its share of toxicity, with overzealous parents and poor leadership coupled with unsavory social media standards, which has now led to me taking some time away from broadcasting! My decision,” he said in a Facebook post.

This man spent 45 years covering sports, especially high school sports.

While I am saddened that he’s stepping down, I understand his frustration. Amateur sports, especially youth sports, has become a mess in the last decade or so. Why? There are a number of reasons.

First, I’ll blame parents who have ridiculous expectations. The number of adults who believe their child will earn a DI scholarship and go onto the pros borders on the bizarre. Less than two-percent of high school athletes will play at NCAA Division I schools, and just one percent receive full-ride scholarships, funds that are awarded for just one year, so if a kid breaks a leg or struggles in the classroom, bye-bye sports dreams.

And then what? Parents who put their kids on the year-long, one-sport merry-go-round, spending what could amount to college tuition on personal coaches, deny their children the chance to branch out and grow. Maybe play an instrument, or perform in a play, or even participate in a different sport, things they should be doing throughout high school. This single-mindedness will doom their children when they can no longer participate in the single thing that occupied their lives. Every athlete has to stop playing at some point. Something that tends to happen when we’re young. As I often mentioned to my students who insisted they would one day be professional athletes, “What happens after that? The average professional career lasts between three and six years. What will you do then?”

Before I go on, note that I spent 40 years officiating amateur sports. I called ice hockey, soccer, and basketball games, but spent the vast majority of my time on football and baseball fields. I realize today how lucky I was that much of my career came before the advent of social media, which has made calling games a nightmare. It used to be that when I made a mistake—Yes, all officials do, just like players and coaches.—the hysteria and verbal assaults were pretty much over when I left the field. Today, however, fans splash video and photos of calls they dislike all over the Internet, often implying the official made the errant call intentionally to benefit a team. Trust me. No official wants to make a bad call. We just do. Sometimes we’re tired from working our day jobs, or we’re hungry, or we just blink. Those of us in the amateur ranks only get one look at a play. There aren’t replay officials or nine-camera angles to check. And yet, we are required to be perfect, which is simply impossible.

Recent studies show that approximately 45% of officials say they have feared for their safety because of the behavior of administrators, players, and fans. One in three officials have received threats or felt unsafe at a game, something I understand since I have, on occassion, required a police escort to my car. So, is it any wonder that roughly 50% of new officials quit within their first two years? Myriad games are being cancelled at youth levels because of a dearth of officials. And this trend will get worse.

Here’s what needs to happen, though I won’t hold my breath. We need to remember the real purpose of kids sports. Children learning teamwork and punctuality, how to follow rules, goal-setting, social skills, and resilience. And, perhaps, most importantly, leadership skills. All of which will make them better human beings.

Maybe, if we adults adjust our expectations the miasma surrounding youth sports will clear. And then my friend will once again pick up his microphone and go back to the thing he loves.

Your Forgotten Sons

Inspired by a true story

Anne Montgomery

Bud Richardville is inducted into the Army as the United States prepares for the invasion of Europe in 1943. A chance comment has Bud assigned to a Graves Registration Company, where his unit is tasked with locating, identifying, and burying the dead. Bud ships out, leaving behind his new wife, Lorraine, a mysterious woman who has stolen his heart but whose secretive nature and shadowy past leave many unanswered questions. When Bud and his men hit the beach at Normandy, they are immediately thrust into the horrors of what working in a graves unit entails. Bud is beaten down by the gruesome demands of his job and losses in his personal life, but then he meets Eva, an optimistic soul who despite the war can see a positive future. Will Eva’s love be enough to save him?

Release Date: June 6, 2024

Pre-Order your copy today

Amazon

Apple Books

Barnes & Nobel

Google Books

Kobo

Review a copy early by going to NetGalley. Sign in here.

Bookstores, libraries, and other booksellers can order copies directly from the Ingram Catalog.

Anne Montgomery’s novels can be found wherever books are sold.

Goodreads

Amazon

4 thoughts on “The youth sports landscape is crumbling

  1. M. F. says:
    M. F.'s avatar

    The kids who do these sports for the love of sport can teach adults to “grow up”. Permit me a moment to “go political”. I was inspired by the words of AB Hernandez facing both the physical and mental challenges of the sport and the public harassment of an adult community aligned against her with grit and the support of her young fellow competitors: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/jun/05/california-ab-hernandez-trump-attacks?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other

    The kids are alright…despite our worst efforts.

    Like

    • annemontgomeryauthor2013 says:
      annemontgomeryauthor2013's avatar

      I agree, Sherm. And I appreciate the way California is handling this. Everybody wins and the kids learn compassion. Now, if only parents would get the message.

      Like

  2. Jeff Leaf says:
    Jeff Leaf's avatar

    Well said. Unfortunately, the people who need to hear your message are not listening.

    The only solution I see is for sports administration and officiating to become hard-asses. We can’t legislate good behavior, only enforce it. Bad behavior must be slapped down immediately. My Psychologist wife, who is also a lawyer, told me that people must be called on their bad behavior at the time they are doing it. I’m not optimistic about that we can change behavior, but maybe we can scare them into keeping their mouths shut and let the players play.

    Oh, well, I can dream.

    Like

    • annemontgomeryauthor2013 says:
      annemontgomeryauthor2013's avatar

      I couldn’t agree more, Jeff. But I sense schools and amateur associations are afraid of parents. When I was officiating, we shut things down quickly, but with inexperienced officials new to the job, it’s often hard for them to adjust. And once the fans, parents, and coaches see you flinch, it’s difficult to get things under control. It’s a delicate dance, believe me. And this crap with the Internet, implying that officials care about who wins an amateur sports event, is not only stupid, but dangerous.

      Like

Leave a reply to M. F. Cancel reply